“Perhaps the truth isn’t satisfying.” (Catholic novelist Muriel Spark)

August 24, 2010

The BBC has an online archive of video interviews conducted with several of the great British novelists of the last century (Iris Murdoch, J. R. R. Tolkien, P. G. Wodehouse, et al.). Here is an interesting bit from the interview with Muriel Spark, discussing her conversion to Catholicism:

Spark: Largely I’m still a Catholic because I can’t believe anything else. I’d often like to, but I can’t.

Host: And you find it a satisfying religion for you?

Spark: No, but I can’t believe anything else. Perhaps the truth isn’t satisfying. It may be that.

Spark was not exactly a saintly role model. It seems that her life parallels Graham Greene in this regard. Both led lives marked especially by “lusts of the flesh,” both experienced profound conversions to the Catholic faith, after which they both wrote their best novels. But the further removed from their conversions, the worse the novels get. Catholicism for both resulted in an introspective deepening and imaginative boost, but the dominance of sin ultimately dampened their genius.

So, what are we to think of Dame Spark’s statement (“Perhaps the truth isn’t satisfying”)? Of course, I heartily agree that the truth condemns our complacency and pet idols, calling us to a radical obedience. Herein we find discomfort. Yet, the truth of the Cross includes the truth of the Resurrection, and this truth is the most satisfying of all truths: life freely given. The Holy Spirit convicts, yes, but he also bears fruit: love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faith, gentleness, and self-control. This was said by Saint Paul, who was equally quite aware of the hardships bestowed by the Lord. Once again, we have a dialectic where discomfort and comfort are united in one expression of truth. If you lose the dialectic, you lose the truth. Unfortunately, we live in an age where the comfort side of the dialectic is elevated over-against the discomfort. In this context, Spark’s statement is refreshing.

Advertisements

8 Responses to ““Perhaps the truth isn’t satisfying.” (Catholic novelist Muriel Spark)”

  1. Francesca said

    I think the truth is satisfying. It’s not a matter of what current one currently needs to lean against.

    • Kevin Davis said

      Very beautiful! A while back, I read a recommendation of The Innocence Mission but I never checked them out — I should have.

  2. Francesca said

    Thanks for your piece on grace and nature. I never read Nick Healy’s piece, and now I’ve printed it out for proper study.

    I’m a big fan of Innocence Mission.

    • Kevin Davis said

      I think you’ll like Healy’s article. It clarified some things for me. I especially like his point about de Lubac’s catholic appropriation of diverse figures across traditions and ages, in contrast to the commentator/manual narrowing of the tradition to predictable epistemological concerns and solutions.

  3. Francesca said

    I have got We Walked in Song, Birds of My Neighbourhood, and the most recent CD (which ‘God is Love’ is on), My Room in the Trees. They are all good.

  4. Francesca said

    I’m still reading Healy’s article.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: